From Noise to Signal to Selbstzweck: Reframing Human Label Variation in the Era of Post-Training in NLP

MCML Authors

Barbara Plank

Prof. Dr.

Principal Investigator

AI and Computational Linguistics

Abstract

Human Label Variation (HLV) refers to legitimate disagreement in annotation that reflects the genuine diversity of human perspectives rather than mere error. For decades, HLV in NLP was dismissed as noise to be discarded, and only slowly over the last decade has it been reframed as a signal for improving model robustness. With the rise of large language models (LLMs), where post-training on human feedback has become central to model alignment, the role of HLV has become increasingly consequential. Yet current preference-learning datasets routinely aggregate multiple annotations into a single label, thereby flattening diverse perspectives into a false universal agreement and erasing precisely the pluralism of human values that alignment aims to preserve. In this position paper, we argue that preserving HLV as an embodiment of human pluralism must be treated as a Selbstzweck - a goal it self when designing AI systems. We call for proactively incorporating HLV into preference datasets and outline actionable steps towards it.

misc

---

Preprint

Oct. 2025

---

Authors

S. Xu • S. T. Y. S. S • B. Plank

---

Links

---

Research Area

 B2 | Natural Language Processing